Wales Institute of Social & Economic Research, Data & Methods
Sefydliad Ymchwil Gymdeithasol ac Economaidd, Data a Dulliau Cymru

Navigation :: Home> News>

Need for Non-Market Institutions for Inter Country Transfers: A lesson from the EU Referendum

6th July 2016


In a new WISERD blog post, entitled 'Need for Non-Market Institutions for Inter Country Transfers: A lesson from the EU Referendum', Professor Shanti Chakravarty, an Emeritus Professor of Economics at Bangor University, reflects on the work of his colleague at Bangor - Professor R. Ross MacKay - in understanding the reasons why the EU might have started to disintegrate.

The 1977 Brussels-commissioned MacDougal report stated that: 

The changing pattern of production and exchange that characterises an integrating Community typically brings gains to some but losses to others. To make integration acceptable to all participants may thus require an explicit distributive mechanism to divide the gains from integration in a politically acceptable way. Failure to attend to this matter may at the least result in a stagnation of the integration process, and at the worst result in secession and dissolution. (MacDougal Report, 1977, vol. 1, p. 60) 

In a paper written for the Cambridge Journal of Economics 1994 Ross argued that the 1992 EU project was being analysed by economists at the time without reference to economic history.  Nation states are defined by fiscal transfers between rich and poor regions, transfers that are politically difficult to achieve between nations.

Professor Chakravarty comments “Ross worried that that 1992 project would fail unless there were built in regional transfers overriding market distribution of fortunes.  In the event, the warning was not heeded.  The cost of Brexit to the EU by far outweighs the cost of solving the Greek debt problem”. 

To read this blog post please click here

Latest News
Young People and Brexit

22nd March 2017

WISERD has recently been awarded ESRC funding to carry out a new interdisciplinary study into how young people in the UK feel about, and are responding to, the most significant policy issue of this Parliament: the UK’s exit from the European Union.


Poverty and Food Banks in Wales

16th March 2017

Poverty and the rise of food banks in Wales were the focus of research shared at WISERD’s latest civil society seminar, held at Cardiff last night. PhD student, David Beck and Dr Hefin Gwilym from Bangor University’s School of Social Sciences presented findings from their research exploring the experience of food poverty in Wales.


Featured Events
28 March, 1:00 pm - 2:00 pm
Executive Boardroom, Visualisation Centre, Aberystwyth University

As part of the WISERD Civil Society Seminar series, Tom Jones OBE presents an insider’s perspective on the role of civil society organizations in policy-making in Wales, the UK and Europe.


26 April, 1:00 pm - 2:00 pm
Aberystwyth University (room to be confirmed)

As part of the WISERD Centre for Welsh Politics and Society Seminar Series, Dr Taulant Guma from the Department of Geography and Earth Sciences at Aberystwyth University presents emerging findings from the WISERD/Civil Society project on ‘Migrants, Minorities and Engagement in Local Civil Society’.