Wales Institute of Social & Economic Research, Data & Methods
Sefydliad Ymchwil Gymdeithasol ac Economaidd, Data a Dulliau Cymru

Navigation :: Home> News>

New Report: Why we need social innovation in home care of the elderly

19th September 2016

Professor Ian Rees Jones collaborates on new Centre for Research on Socio-Cultural Change (CRESC) report.

The joint report launched on 12 September 2016 at the Fairer Futures: Reshaping Care for Older People symposium, argues that, with a social innovation approach, local authorities could provide better home care which benefited carers and cared.

Published to coincide with the symposium, a collaboration between Alliance Manchester Business School’s Health Services Research Centre, WISERD, the Fairness at Work Research Centre and the Manchester Institute for Collaborative Research into Ageing, the report argues that having good intentions alone in adult care is not enough.

The findings reveal that the central state and expert community have promoted the worthy aims of personalisation of care and outcomes-based commissioning. However, the report argues that (partly as a result of austerity cuts) adult social care is a sector now facing multiple crises: there is a financial crisis in terms of service cuts, a care quality crisis, a workforce recruitment and retention crisis and a provider crisis resulting from squeezed margins.

Report co-author Karel Williams, Professor of Accounting and Political Economy at Alliance Manchester Business School says: “There is a painful gap between the policy makers’ rhetorical promise of choice, control and independence afforded by home care and the lived experience of the majority of the 600,000 old people who receive home care. This may keep people in their own homes and living independently but it is not delivering consistently high quality care.”

The report argues:

  • A hyperactive central state has driven reforms in the sector, with local authorities encouraged to view home care through a narrow market citizenship lens. Personal budgets, direct payments and local authority sponsorship of competitive markets have disappointed in the case of elderly because they are built on a limited understanding of choice, control and independence, and because they accept as given the business model of providers and the commissioning practice of local authorities.
  • The activity specifics of home care intersect with the providers’ sectoral business model to create an intractable mess so that putting more state money in is a necessary but not sufficient condition of reform. Home care is delivered by travelling carers on rounds performing physical maintenance tasks on short visits. The branch retail business model of organising rounds produces firms with different cost structures and discretion about pursuing objectives of resilience or cash generation: underpaid providers demand a fair price from Local Authorities but there cannot sensibly be one price for all firms in an area.
  • What we need is a new agenda of radical social innovation that promotes a much broader notion of full citizenship for carers and cared who both have rights to a decent living. The report argues that change should be led by authority commissioners, empowered by mobilisation of a political coalition for change; we need to engage old people and other citizens in political debate and choices about provision for the elderly.

For the proposed recommendations and full research findings, download the report here.

Latest News
Young People and Brexit

22nd March 2017

WISERD has recently been awarded ESRC funding to carry out a new interdisciplinary study into how young people in the UK feel about, and are responding to, the most significant policy issue of this Parliament: the UK’s exit from the European Union.


Poverty and Food Banks in Wales

16th March 2017

Poverty and the rise of food banks in Wales were the focus of research shared at WISERD’s latest civil society seminar, held at Cardiff last night. PhD student, David Beck and Dr Hefin Gwilym from Bangor University’s School of Social Sciences presented findings from their research exploring the experience of food poverty in Wales.


Featured Events
28 March, 1:00 pm - 2:00 pm
Executive Boardroom, Visualisation Centre, Aberystwyth University

As part of the WISERD Civil Society Seminar series, Tom Jones OBE presents an insider’s perspective on the role of civil society organizations in policy-making in Wales, the UK and Europe.


26 April, 1:00 pm - 2:00 pm
Aberystwyth University (room to be confirmed)

As part of the WISERD Centre for Welsh Politics and Society Seminar Series, Dr Taulant Guma from the Department of Geography and Earth Sciences at Aberystwyth University presents emerging findings from the WISERD/Civil Society project on ‘Migrants, Minorities and Engagement in Local Civil Society’.